Thursday, July 19, 2007

First Interim Report of the April Riot Commission of Inquiry

The Commission of Inquiry into the 2006 April Civil Unrest in Honiara released its first interim report to the public this morning (see report here...I wish they'd PDF it or something...)

The Commission is chaired by Brian Brunton (a former PNG National Court judge). The other members of the Commission are Noel Levi (PNG), Waeta Ben Tabusasi (Solomon Islands) and Charles Levo (Solomon Islands).

I haven't yet read the entire report, but the points made in the Executive Summary include the following:
there is evidence of a degree of consensus amongst political groups present in Honiara, that in the event of a prime minister being elected by Parliament who was not of their choice, or liking, they would force a regime change; despite this, senior officers controlling Solomon Islands security had (a) inadequately assessed the risks of civil unrest associated with the election of a prime minister;(b) no detailed plan to deal with potential unrest;(c) insufficient numbers of police, insufficient trained riot-control capability and insufficient equipment to deal with the risks of civil unrest associated with the election of a prime minister.

    Of considerable interest is this point:

    The Commission is of the opinion that the assertions by some witnesses that the outbreak of violence at Parliament House was (a) spontaneous, (b) a reaction to pent-up anger, (c) driven by the need to get rid of corruption, (d) driven by the need to break Chinese influence on political groups, or (e) a reaction to the Participating Police Force firing either flash-grenades or tear gas are, in part, contrived, do not ring true, and conflict with other evidence (such as footage, the throwing of stones, and statements of other witnesses).

    Hmmm. I'll read the report before I comment on that one!!

    No comments: